• Casey Rogers's avatar
    Make `future` and `stream` required arguments in their respective builder widgets (#125838) · 4d86f5d0
    Casey Rogers authored
    cc'ing existing conversation participants: @domesticmouse @srawlins
    cc'ing to request review: @goderbauer 
    
    This PR makes the following constructor arguments required:
    1. `FutureBuilder.future`
    2. `StreamBuilderBase.stream`
    3. `StreamBuilder.stream`
    
    This fixes:
    https://github.com/flutter/flutter/issues/83081
    https://github.com/flutter/flutter/issues/125188 (dupe of 83081)
    
    This obviates:
    https://github.com/dart-lang/linter/issues/4309
    (I suggest we skip straight to merging this PR as this should be a low impact breaking change-assuming few to no devs are intentionally using the builders without their relevant arguments, however we could always merge 4309 first and then this)
    https://github.com/flutter/flutter/pull/83101 
    (The above PR required that at least one of future and initial data be non-null, this is undesirable as there are plenty of valid reasons to have both arguments be null)
    
    See above issues for a deeper dive, but here is a summary:
    It is very easy for a developer to forget to specify `future` or `stream` when using the respective `*Builder` widgets. This produces a non-obvious failure where the UI sits in a "no data yet received" state. It is easy for a dev to misinterpret this as the async work backing the future/stream hanging and they thus waste a lot of time trying to debug the async work.
    As such, we should require these two constructor arguments to make it impossible/much harder for devs to make this time-wasting mistake.
    
    This is a breaking change. However, it should break only a small number of active projects given that using a builder without specifying `future` or `stream` seems highly niche.
    The only place I've found non-accidental examples of this is in widget tests where you're calling `pumpWidget` with and without these arguments to test `*Builder.didUpdateWidget`'s behavior. In this and similar cases, it is a trivial fix to add `future: null`/`stream: null`.
    
    *If you had to change anything in the [flutter/tests] repo, include a link to the migration guide as per the [breaking change policy].*
    4d86f5d0
Name
Last commit
Last update
..
flutter Loading commit data...
flutter_driver Loading commit data...
flutter_goldens Loading commit data...
flutter_goldens_client Loading commit data...
flutter_localizations Loading commit data...
flutter_test Loading commit data...
flutter_tools Loading commit data...
flutter_web_plugins Loading commit data...
fuchsia_remote_debug_protocol Loading commit data...
integration_test Loading commit data...
analysis_options.yaml Loading commit data...